Mennonite Church USA v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security

Litigation Content

ICAP represents a broad coalition of 27 national and regional faith-based organizations, including Jewish and Christian denominations, in their challenge to the Department of Homeland Security’s rescission of its long-standing “sensitive locations” policy. For over 30 years, this policy restricted federal immigration enforcement at or near houses of worship, schools, and hospitals. The sudden reversal of this policy in 2025 removed the restrictions on, and presumption against, enforcement at houses of worship. Coupled with an aggressive increase in enforcement efforts, DHS’s policy rescission has caused reduced attendance at the plaintiffs’ religious services and creates an imminent threat of disruption to the plaintiffs’ sacred spaces.

The lawsuit alleges that the government’s actions substantially burden the plaintiffs’ religious exercise, in violation of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and the First Amendment. Furthermore, ICAP argues that the agency’s failure to provide an adequate justification for such a significant policy shift violates the Administrative Procedure Act. By leading this litigation, ICAP is defending the right of religious institutions to serve their communities and exercise their faith without the chilling effect of unlawful government intrusion.

Oral Argument:


More of our cases

CASA v. Trump (2025)

ICAP represents a class of people for whom President Trump attempted to deny birthright citizenship by Executive Order.

Status

Decision issued

Court

U.S. Supreme Court No. 24A884

4th Circuit No. 25-1153 / 21-2188

D. Md. No. 25-00021

View

State of Indiana ex rel. Rokita v. Marté

ICAP is defending Monroe County Sheriff Ruben Marté and the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office against a lawsuit brought by the Indiana Attorney General alleging that the Sheriff must amend his immigration policy to allow for greater involvement of officers in immigration enforcement.

Status

Briefing is ongoing

Court

Monroe County Circuit Court No. 53COG-2407-PL-001733

View

U.S. v. 14.259 Acres of Land in Doña Ana County, New Mexico

ICAP represents the Catholic Diocese of Las Cruces, New Mexico, in defending against the United States Government’s efforts to exercise its power of eminent domain to take Diocesan property for the purpose of building a border wall that is contrary to Catholic values and teachings on the holy site, Mount Cristo Rey.

Status

Briefing is ongoing

Court

D. N.M. No. 2:26-cv-01458-KG-GBW

View

U.S. v. County of Washtenaw

ICAP is defending Washtenaw County Sheriff Alyshia Dyer and the Washtenaw County Sheriff’s Office against a lawsuit that challenges their policy of limiting local involvement in federal immigration enforcement.

Status

Decision issued

Court

E.D. Mich. No. 26-cv-11166

View
See all cases